Nespresso and Keurig are two of the world’s biggest single-serve coffee machine manufacturers out there right now. If you are looking for a single-serve machine, chances are high that you might have to choose between these two. That is where we come in. We decided to put these two giants into a head to head comparison and find out their good and bad qualities. In today’s Nespresso VS Keurig showdown, we’ll cover a few specific categories from both sides and hopefully, by the end of this article, you’ll have the answers you were looking for. So sit back, relax and join us as we get on with our comparison.
Overview on Nespresso and Keurig
When it comes to the USA single-serve coffee market, we can easily conclude that Keurig has the upper hand there. They own 61% of both coffee pod and machine market. Whereas Nespresso only managed 4%. However, Nespresso is more dominant in the European market. Even though they both make single-serve brewers, they have quite a lot of differences.
Nespresso coffee machines are usually single-serve, pod-based espresso machines. The companies models are split into two lines: The OriginalLine – that brews only espressos and The VertuoLine – that brews espressos and coffee.
Some of their models feature a built-in frother, which will make it possible to make cappuccinos, lattes and other beverages. For those models that don’t feature a frother, you can add their hand-pump frother. It has proven to work quite well and it comes included with some other models.
- Better quality beverage
- Better built quality
- Swiss-made machine
- Nespresso capsules are recyclable
- Awesome custom size feature
- Very few selections of brew
- More expensive than Keurig
Keurig is the number one single-serve coffee manufacturer in the US and they have released roughly around 50 models in their decade of dominance. One of the reasons why Keurig dominates the machine and coffee pod market is because of their Keurig 2.0 brewing system. This system only allows the usage of Keurig-licensed K-Cups. This means that you can’t use other pods on their machines. However, there is a way around that by hacking the system, but that is a whole different topic.
- Over 50 different models to choose from
- Over 400 brew options
- Many more pods available
- Has models that brew from 4-30 oz
- Generally more affordable to buy and use
- Coffee quality is not as good as Nespresso (mainly due to the brewing method)
- Keurig isn’t as environmentally friendly as Nespresso (pods are not recyclable)
Key Features to Look Out For
Now that we have a general idea on both of these coffee manufacturers it is time to have a look at some of the key features you have to take into consideration.
This is usually one of the decisive factors when you’re making any sort of purchase. According to recent statistics, Keurig machines are far more affordable than Nespresso machines. However, some of the latest models from Nespresso have come at a more reasonable price. Perhaps this is a new strategy imposed by the company in order to be more competitive. Keep in mind that the cost doesn’t stop there, you need to take into consideration the money you’ll spend on coffee pods as well. Keurig has more affordable pods as well. Because of the larger pod size, the Nespresso pods are more expensive. Furthermore, the Keurig pods offer you the option of a reusable filter. This makes it possible for you to brew your own grounds.
Nespresso vs Keurig: Selection of brews
Keurigs K-Cup pods offer a variety of more than 400 brews from 60 brands, which include some of the best selling brands. These include hot chocolate, coffee, lemonade, coffee and fruity drinks. Furthermore, the reusable K-Cup filter allows you to fill it with the coffee of your choice, giving you personalization. These reusable filters are also an environment-friendly option, seeing as most of the K-pods are not recyclable yet.
On the other hand, Nespresso includes only 17 different types. Even though the lack of variety is a disadvantage, they shouldn’t be underestimated. Because, what they lack in variety, they more than makeup with quality. Their coffee is of the highest quality and if you can overlook the limited selection available, then this is a great choice.
Recycling and Environmentally Friendly
The K-Pods from Keurig are not recyclable yet. However, they are making an effort to produce recyclable ones. According to their website, the pods made in Canada are 100% recyclable. The company also makes recyclable pods for the US market, but you need to make sure it has the green symbol on it. Keurig also stated that it is their goal to make all K-Cups recyclable by 2020.
Nespresso, on the other hand, advertises their pods as easily recyclable, but it’s not that simple. However, the company is doing a great job in making it easier for its users to recycle the pods. If you are a capsule subscriber, you have the option to trade your used pods for fresh new ones on your doorstep. In addition to that, the company also includes a free pod-recycling bag with prepaid UPS shipping labels. Users can mail these bags back to the company from any UPS store. Users also have the option to bring the used pods to a collection site or a boutique retailer and the company takes care of the rest.
Storage, Design and Usage
Nespresso has the reputation of having a sleek and stylish design. Their models even look luxurious. In addition to that, they offer a wide range of colour options making them easier to fit into any interior. On the other hand, Keurig’s models are larger, mainly due to the bigger water reservoirs. Both companies have included an intuitive design in their models’ control panels, making them equally user-friendly. One perk that the Nespresso has is that it automatically ejects used capsules.
Nespresso vs Keurig: Brewing Methods
The Keurig has adopted a more traditional approach in the form of pressure brewing. This works in a way that the machine punches two holes in the bottom and in the centre of the K-Cups. The pressure squeezes out the coffee from the cup. It usually takes around 45 seconds to around a minute for the coffee to brew.
Nespresso, on the other hand, has adopted a more modern type of coffee brewing. Their machines use centrifusion brewing method. This increases the contact between coffee beans and hot water, resulting in a layer of foamy crema at the top of every cup. Some Nespresso models include an advanced centrifusion method. This combines the centrifugal action with the water fusion, which spins the capsule at 7000 rpm. After that, the machine penetrates the capsule around the edges and in the centre, then water is injected and pressed from 20 openings. This results in better brew and coffee quality.
Time and temperature are the two main factors that determine the quality of the coffee when brewing. Nespresso uses barcode scan technology. This allows the machine to read what time and temperature combination to use when brewing. This results in a much better coffee brew. The thin layer of crema is all thanks to the centrifugal brewing method. This only enhances the taste and the aroma of the coffee.
Verdict – Nespresso vs Keurig
There you have it, folks, we’ve gotten to the end of our Nespresso VS Keurig duel and it is time to wrap things up! It is a very close call between these two single-serve coffee giants. Simply because they are both great coffee machine manufacturers. In the end, it all comes down to individual taste and preference. Both are easy to use and maintain no doubt here. Keurig is more affordable both on short term and on the long term. However, Nespresso provides better coffee quality, at least when it comes to espressos. On the other hand, Keurig has a larger variety of drinks to choose from. But Nespresso is more environmentally friendly.
So to summarize, if you are someone who is a casual drinker that doesn’t mind the taste but likes to have a lot of drinking options than you should go for Keurig machines. If you are someone who likes a specific taste in espresso and cares about the environment, you should try Nespresso machines.