Best Organic Keurig Coffee Pods – Ultimate Buying Guide

People who love coffee simply can’t stop improving their coffee drinking experience. It seems that every time they drink coffee – they are looking for ways and means to make it better, stronger and tastier. This includes finding the best Keurig organic coffee pods, the best brewer, the best coffee grinder and whatnot.

Is this one of your dreams too? Drinking top-notch coffee and having it in the comfort of your home?

You don’t have to hire a barista for your kitchen, all you need is a good coffee maker and even greater coffee pods.

We have the brewer – Keurig is one of the best coffee maker brands you can find, but what about the pods? Do you only use the ones that come originally with the brewer? Or, do you like trying out the different kinds and tastes? Of course, you want to get the absolute best ones.

Many people were kind-of disappointed to learn that the initial coffee pods were far from organic, and some were even unhealthy with suspicious ingredients in them.

Luckily for you, Keurig develops their brewers in such a way that you can use different, not only Keurig pods, and we’ve done the research for you. In the following text, you’ll get the ideas of the best organic Keurig coffee pods that you should consider using if you want to drink healthy and organic, yet tasty coffee from your Keurig brewer.

So, without further ado, here are your best organic Keurig coffee pods options:

1. Best Overall Organic Keurig Coffee Pods: Caza Trail Coffee

If you are looking for a cup of joe that will fill all standards you can possibly have – taste, aroma, thickness and the ability to wake you up nicely in the morning – Caza is your brand. Their Trail Coffee, just like the other pods they offer is completely made of pure 100% Arabica coffee. Basically, this ensures a perfect balance of aroma, body and flavour.


  • Budget-friendly
  • Organic and kosher
  • Great for anyone’s taste
  • High-quality blend from proven locations


  • Not a great choice for those who like extra-strong coffee

What we really love about this Keurig K-cup compatible pods is that they are bold while being smooth at the same time. Also, they have a well-rounded finish for the perfect amount of acidity of the taste.

Since they are on this list, it is needless to say that they are USDA certified for being both organic and kosher.

Best organic Keurig coffee pods

2. Best Taste: San Francisco Bay Onecup Organic Coffee Pods

The thing that made the San Francisco Bay Onecup coffee pods so famous is not only the fact that they are organic. Specifically, the most notable thing about them is their really exotic, rich taste. You cannot possibly mistake them for anything else. After all, they have the richest taste on the market, regardless of what your brewer is like.


  • Eco-friendly with commercially compostable materials
  • Rich and exotic
  • Handpicked beans
  • Reliable Brand


  • You need to visit a special facility to actually compost the used pods

If you don’t have a brewer that does a good extraction, you’ll love these pods, as there isn’t a need for a superior extraction process. However, if you have a Keurig brewer, you’ll be swept off your feet by the amazing taste. It is the equivalent of a perfect cup of coffee.

What we really love about them is that they have exotic flavours of beans from Indonesia, Guatemala, Mexico, and Colombia. Additionally, those with distinguished taste will notice a slight touch of citrus taste in the coffee. And, believe us, this tastes much better than you’d expect.

3. Best Strong Coffee: Newman’s Own Special Blend

Newman’s Own is one of the most reputable coffee brands on the market – and they are a really philanthropic company as well, which is why we have to give them recognition.


  • Reputable brand
  • USDA certification for being organic
  • Rich taste
  • Convenient packaging of 80 pods


  • Recent changes in packaging and design make people suspicious of changes in quality

On the subject of their Keurig compatible coffee pods – you have a lot of different pods to choose from, but the Special Blend is our favourite. It is basically a 100% Arabica coffee for full-bodied flavour, which will wake you up nicely in just a manner of seconds.

4. Unique Taste: Green Mountain Sumatran Reserve

For those who are looking for something special for their coffee needs in the morning, we present to you the best Keurig organic coffee pods with a unique taste – Green Mountain’s Sumatran Reserve.


  • Indonesian blend from high-quality beans
  • Distinctive rich bold taste
  • Budget-friendly
  • Convenient 24-pod package


  • Plastic pods, not eco-friendly

As you’d suggest, these pods have Fair Trade certification for being organic. So, this makes them both healthy and safe for daily usage.

Also, what we really enjoy about them is the fact they are extremely budget-friendly. So, regardless of how much cups of coffee you drink on a daily basis, you can enjoy these pods without it affecting your budget.

5. Most Healthy: Healthwise Low Acid Coffee 100% Colombian Supremo

The last but definitely not least item on our best Keurig organic coffee pods are the Healthwise Low Acid pods. These are made and roasted with the highest-quality, certified Colombian Supremo Arabica beans, which basically speaks a lot for their quality.


  • Smooth coffee
  • Healthy and kosher
  • Great for those who have health-problems from acid coffee


  • Not really strong

Also, their process of Techno Roasting is approved by the FDA. Basically, this makes them even healthier. Especially since they have a minimized amount of acids. And, we all know acids are bad for people with heartburns.

In addition to this, the process of roasting is finely created. Specifically, it protects the antioxidants, the essential minerals and vitamins from the coffee, making it a really healthy habit to drink coffee in the morning.

Moreover, the cups are produced in a nut-free facility and besides being certified as organic. Also, they are certified as Kosher. This, in the end, results in Healthwise offering you a really nice, morning coffee option.

Most healthy best organic Keurig coffee pods

Conclusion – Which are the best organic Keurig coffee pods for you?

If you were looking for a healthy, organic option to start your mornings with, the list above gives you an abundance of great choices. These are the best Keurig organic coffee pods. So, you can expect nothing less than the perfect cup of coffee in the morning with either choice.

Just make your pick according to your own specific needs and preferences. We promise you, you won’t be disappointed. Yet, you’ll wake up with a smile on your face and a high-quality, rich cup of coffee in your hands.


Leave a Comment